Otto, Diesel and dual cycles

Otto, Diesel and Dual cycles under the air-standard model: definitions, assumptions, state relations, efficiencies, comparisons, mep, formulas, and exam-ready numericals.

Drafted with Aria, reviewed by the AiCanCode.org team · Updated . How we write and check our notes. Spotted an error? Use Give Feedback at the bottom of the page.

Why it matters

Internal combustion engines (petrol SI, diesel CI) are designed around idealized cycles that predict efficiency and work output. Understanding the Otto, Diesel and Dual cycles lets you estimate performance trends, choose design parameters like compression ratio, and interpret test results in engine labs and core interviews.

Key ideas

  • Air-standard modeling

    • The cycles are analyzed under the air-standard assumptions: (i) the working fluid is air, which behaves as an ideal gas with constant specific heats (cold-air-standard, typically at 300 K); (ii) compression and expansion are internally reversible and adiabatic (isentropic); (iii) combustion is replaced by external heat addition; (iv) exhaust is replaced by external heat rejection; (v) one open cycle ≈ one closed cycle with the same net work.
    • Take γ = c_p/c_v ≈ 1.4 for air, c_p ≈ 1.005 kJ/(kg·K), c_v ≈ 0.718 kJ/(kg·K), R = 0.287 kJ/(kg·K).
    • Sign convention: heat added to the system positive; work done by the system positive.
  • Common state ratios and parameters

    • Compression ratio (r): r = V1/V2, where 1→2 is isentropic compression and V1 is maximum, V2 is minimum cylinder volume.
    • Cut-off ratio (ρ): volume ratio across the constant-pressure heat addition. For Diesel: ρ = V3/V2. For Dual: ρ = V4/V3 (since 3→4 is at constant pressure). Always “after/before” the constant-pressure segment.
    • Pressure ratio during constant-volume heat addition (α): α = P3/P2 in the Dual cycle’s constant-volume step 2→3. For Otto, the analogous ratio is sometimes denoted r_p = P3/P2.
  • The cycles (process sequence, P–V and T–S in words)

    • Otto cycle (SI engines, petrol): 1→2 isentropic compression; 2→3 constant-volume heat addition; 3→4 isentropic expansion; 4→1 constant-volume heat rejection. Signature: vertical constant-volume heat-add/heat-reject lines on P–V.
    • Diesel cycle (CI engines, diesel): 1→2 isentropic compression; 2→3 constant-pressure heat addition; 3→4 isentropic expansion; 4→1 constant-volume heat rejection. Signature: horizontal constant-pressure heat-add segment on P–V.
    • Dual (limited pressure) cycle (modern high-speed CI): 1→2 isentropic compression; 2→3 constant-volume heat addition; 3→4 constant-pressure heat addition; 4→5 isentropic expansion; 5→1 constant-volume heat rejection. Signature: heat-add split between a vertical (constant V) segment and a horizontal (constant P) segment on P–V.
  • Isentropic relations for ideal gas (used repeatedly)

    • T2/T1 = r^(γ−1), P2/P1 = r^γ along 1→2; similarly during expansion T4/T3 = (V3/V4)^(γ−1), etc.
  • Thermal efficiency (air-standard)

    • Otto efficiency: η_th,Otto = 1 − 1/r^(γ−1). Depends only on r (and γ). Higher r or γ increases efficiency. Key derivation idea: use q_in = c_v(T3−T2), q_out = c_v(T4−T1), and isentropic T–V relations to eliminate intermediate temperatures.
    • Diesel efficiency: η_th,Diesel = 1 − (1/r^(γ−1)) · [(ρ^γ − 1)/(γ(ρ − 1))], where ρ = V3/V2. Limiting to ρ→1 recovers the Otto result.
    • Dual efficiency: η_th,Dual = 1 − (1/r^(γ−1)) · [(α ρ^γ − 1)/((α − 1) + γα(ρ − 1))]. Limits: α→1 gives Diesel; ρ→1 gives Otto.
    • Outline for Dual derivation (exam sketch): write heat added q_in = c_v(T3−T2) + c_p(T4−T3) = c_v T2[(α−1) + γα(ρ−1)], and heat rejected q_out = c_v(T5−T1). Use isentropic relations to show T5/T1 = α ρ^γ. Then η = 1 − q_out/q_in leads to the standard formula.
  • Why devices differ from the ideal

    • Real engines have variable specific heats (γ drops as T rises), heat loss to walls, finite combustion duration (not perfectly at constant V or P), gas exchange (pumping) work, friction, and combustion irreversibilities. These reduce indicated efficiency below air-standard predictions. Knocking in SI engines limits r; ignition delay and mixing control CI combustion (often approximated by Dual instead of pure Diesel).
  • Performance trends and standard comparisons

    • At the same r and γ, the thermal efficiencies rank: Otto > Dual > Diesel. Intuition: for a given compression, moving more of heat addition toward constant volume raises peak temperature at smaller volume, reducing exhaust temperature and q_out.
    • For a given r and given maximum pressure and temperature constraints, the Dual cycle can be tuned (α, ρ) to trade off efficiency and specific work (and peak pressure). In practice, CI engines often operate closer to Dual than pure Diesel.
  • Mean effective pressure (mep)

    • Mean effective pressure condenses net work per cycle into an equivalent constant pressure on the piston: mep = W_net / V_s, where V_s = V1 − V2 is the swept volume per cycle (per kg in air-standard analysis via specific volumes). High mep indicates greater specific work (power density) for given displacement.
  • Standard cases and limiting cases

    • Dual → Diesel when α→1; Dual → Otto when ρ→1.
    • As r→∞ (not practical), η→1 for all three ideal cycles.
    • As ρ→1 in Diesel, η_Diesel → η_Otto; as ρ grows large, η_Diesel decreases for fixed r.
  • What to remember for exams

    • Definitions: r, ρ, α, γ; the exact process sequence for each cycle; isentropic T–V and P–V relations; the three η_th formulae and their limits; mep definition; and how to compute state properties step-by-step.

Formulas

T2 / T1 = r^(γ − 1) Ideal gas, isentropic compression 1→2 in Otto/Diesel/Dual. T in K, r = V1/V2 (dimensionless), γ = c_p/c_v (dimensionless).

P2 / P1 = r^γ Ideal gas, isentropic compression 1→2. P in kPa (or Pa), r = V1/V2, γ dimensionless.

η_th,Otto = 1 − 1 / r^(γ − 1) Air-standard Otto cycle thermal efficiency. r dimensionless, γ dimensionless. Valid for ideal-gas, constant-γ model.

η_th,Diesel = 1 − (1 / r^(γ − 1)) · [ (ρ^γ − 1) / (γ (ρ − 1)) ] Air-standard Diesel cycle thermal efficiency. ρ = V3/V2 (cut-off ratio, dimensionless). γ, r as defined. Constant-γ model.

η_th,Dual = 1 − (1 / r^(γ − 1)) · [ (α ρ^γ − 1) / ( (α − 1) + γ α (ρ − 1) ) ] Air-standard Dual (limited-pressure) cycle efficiency. α = P3/P2 during constant-volume heat addition (dimensionless), ρ as cut-off ratio across constant-pressure heat addition (dimensionless), r, γ as defined.

q_in,Otto = c_v (T3 − T2) Heat added per kg for Otto (constant-volume heat addition). c_v in kJ/(kg·K), T in K.

q_in,Diesel = c_p (T3 − T2) = γ c_v (T3 − T2) Heat added per kg for Diesel (constant-pressure heat addition). c_p in kJ/(kg·K), T in K.

q_in,Dual = c_v T2 [ (α − 1) + γ α (ρ − 1) ] Heat added per kg for Dual (split heat addition). c_v in kJ/(kg·K). Requires α and ρ.

q_out = c_v (T_exh − T_intake) = c_v (T5 − T1) Heat rejected per kg for all three (constant-volume rejection). c_v in kJ/(kg·K); T5 at end of expansion, T1 at start of compression.

w_net = q_in − q_out Net work per kg for all cycles. Units kJ/kg. Positive if cycle produces work.

mep = w_net / (v1 − v2) Mean effective pressure. w_net in kJ/kg; v1, v2 specific volumes in m³/kg; mep in kPa (since 1 kJ/m³ = 1 kPa). Applicable once state 1 and r are known.

v = R T / P Ideal gas state relation for specific volume. v in m³/kg, R = 0.287 kJ/(kg·K), T in K, P in kPa.

For Diesel: T3 = T2 ρ, T4 = T3 (ρ / r)^(γ − 1) Across constant-pressure heating (2→3) and isentropic expansion (3→4). T in K; ρ = V3/V2.

For Dual: T3 = α T2, T4 = ρ T3 = α ρ T2, T5 = T4 ( (ρ / r)^(γ − 1) ) Constant-volume then constant-pressure heating, then isentropic expansion. T in K; α, ρ, r as defined.

Worked examples

Example 1 — Direct application (Otto efficiency) Given: Compression ratio r = 8; specific heat ratio γ = 1.4. Find air-standard thermal efficiency.

Steps:

  1. Formula: η_th,Otto = 1 − 1 / r^(γ − 1).
  2. Compute r^(γ − 1) = 8^0.4. 8^0.4 ≈ 2.297.
  3. η_th = 1 − 1/2.297 = 1 − 0.435 = 0.565.

Answer: η_th ≈ 0.565 (56.5%).

Example 2 — Dual cycle with full state calculation, efficiency, work and mep Given: Dual cycle with r = 16, α = 1.6, ρ = 1.5; intake conditions P1 = 100 kPa, T1 = 300 K; γ = 1.4; c_v = 0.718 kJ/(kg·K); c_p = 1.005 kJ/(kg·K); R = 0.287 kJ/(kg·K). Compute efficiency, net work per kg, and mep.

Assumptions: Air-standard, constant γ; internally reversible compression/expansion; heat addition split as given (α, ρ); constant-volume heat rejection.

Steps:

  1. Isentropic compression 1→2:

    • T2 = T1 r^(γ − 1) = 300 K × 16^0.4 = 300 × 3.031 = 909.3 K.
    • P2 = P1 r^γ = 100 kPa × 16^1.4 = 100 × 48.50 = 4,850 kPa.
  2. Constant-volume heat addition 2→3 (α = P3/P2 = T3/T2):

    • T3 = α T2 = 1.6 × 909.3 = 1,454.9 K.
    • P3 = α P2 = 1.6 × 4,850 = 7,760 kPa.
  3. Constant-pressure heat addition 3→4 (ρ = V4/V3):

    • T4 = ρ T3 = 1.5 × 1,454.9 = 2,182.4 K.
    • P4 = P3 = 7,760 kPa (by definition of constant pressure).
  4. Isentropic expansion 4→5 to V5 = V1:

    • Temperature drop: T5 = T4 × ( (V4/V5)^(γ − 1) ) = 2,182.4 × ( (ρ/r)^0.4 ) = 2,182.4 × ( (1.5/16)^0.4 ) = 2,182.4 × 0.388 = 846.8 K.
  5. Heat interactions per kg:

    • Heat added: q_in = c_v T2 [ (α − 1) + γ α (ρ − 1) ] = 0.718 × 909.3 × [ (1.6 − 1) + 1.4 × 1.6 × (1.5 − 1) ] = 0.718 × 909.3 × [ 0.6 + 1.12 ] = 0.718 × 909.3 × 1.72 = 1,124.0 kJ/kg (rounded).
    • Heat rejected: q_out = c_v (T5 − T1) = 0.718 × (846.8 − 300) = 392.6 kJ/kg.
    • Net work: w_net = q_in − q_out = 1,124.0 − 392.6 = 731.4 kJ/kg.
  6. Thermal efficiency:

    • η = w_net / q_in = 731.4 / 1,124.0 = 0.651 ≈ 65.1%.
    • Check with formula: η = 1 − (1/r^(γ − 1)) × (α ρ^γ − 1)/((α − 1) + γ α (ρ − 1)) = 1 − (1/3.031) × (1.6 × 1.5^1.4 − 1)/1.72 = 0.651 (consistent within rounding).
  7. Mean effective pressure:

    • Specific volumes: v1 = R T1 / P1 = 0.287 × 300 / 100 = 0.861 m³/kg; v2 = v1 / r = 0.861 / 16 = 0.0538 m³/kg.
    • Swept volume v_s = v1 − v2 = 0.861 − 0.0538 = 0.8072 m³/kg.
    • mep = w_net / v_s = 731.4 kJ/kg / 0.8072 m³/kg = 906.6 kPa = 9.07 bar.

Answers: η ≈ 65.1%; w_net ≈ 731.4 kJ/kg; mep ≈ 0.907 MPa (≈ 9.07 bar).

Common mistakes

  • Using γ inconsistently between compression and expansion (keep γ constant under cold-air-standard unless a variable-γ model is specified).
  • Forgetting that η_Otto depends only on r (and γ), not on how much heat is added.
  • Using P in bar with R in kJ/(kg·K) without unit consistency (use kPa with R = 0.287 kJ/(kg·K) to get v in m³/kg).
  • Taking Diesel heat rejection as constant pressure (it is constant volume in the standard air-standard Diesel model).
  • Confusing “cut-off ratio ρ” with “expansion ratio”; in these ideal cycles the geometric expansion ratio equals r, but ρ pertains only to the constant-pressure heat-add portion.
  • Computing mep with total cylinder volume instead of swept volume (use V1 − V2, or v1 − v2 in specific terms).

For GATE ME

  • Direct formula questions: compute η_th for Otto/Diesel/Dual given r, ρ, α, γ; identify limiting cases (α→1 or ρ→1) and rank efficiencies at the same r.
  • State-point calculations: starting from P1, T1, r and (for Diesel/Dual) ρ and/or α, compute T2, P2, T3, P3, T4, T5, and then q_in, q_out, w_net, mep.
  • Design/comparison: given a constraint (e.g., fixed r and peak pressure), compare which cycle yields higher η or mep, or determine α and ρ to meet a specified peak pressure or maximum temperature.
  • Practice checklist: memorize the three η_th formulae; master isentropic T–V and P–V relations; be comfortable moving between specific volumes (via v = RT/P) and ratios (r, ρ, α); carry units carefully; verify answers against limiting cases for sanity.

Quick check

  1. For the same compression ratio and γ, which cycle has the highest air-standard efficiency among Otto, Diesel and Dual?
  2. In the Dual cycle, setting α = 1 reduces it to which cycle? What about setting ρ = 1?
  3. Estimate η_th for an air-standard Otto cycle with r = 7 and γ = 1.4.

Answers: 1) Otto > Dual > Diesel. 2) α = 1 → Diesel; ρ = 1 → Otto. 3) η ≈ 1 − 1/7^0.4 ≈ 0.54 (≈ 54%).

Finished this topic? Mark it so your progress, study plan and readiness keep up.

Stuck on something here?