First Year Engineering is coming soon

We're still writing and reviewing the notes for every subject, and we'll open it when every subject is ready. Meanwhile you can practise aptitude, ask Aria about any subject, or see the branches that are ready.

Hardness of water and its determination

Hardness of water: definitions (temporary/permanent), units (as CaCO3), chemistry (Ca2+/Mg2+), and determination methods (EDTA complexometric titration, soap titration), with calculations and exam-focused steps.

Drafted with Aria, reviewed by the AiCanCode.org team · Updated . How we write and check our notes. Spotted an error? Use Give Feedback at the bottom of the page.

Why it matters

Engineers use water in boilers, cooling towers, process streams, and laboratories. Hard water forms scale and wastes energy; measuring hardness quickly and correctly lets you select and control softening methods and prevent boiler troubles and corrosion.

Key ideas

  • Permanent (non‑carbonate) hardness — Hardness due to chlorides, sulfates, nitrates of Ca2+ and Mg2+ (e.g., CaSO4, MgCl2). It does not decompose on boiling.
  • Total hardness (TH) — Sum of calcium hardness and magnesium hardness, reported as mg/L as CaCO3. Relation: TH = carbonate hardness (CH) + non‑carbonate hardness (NCH).
  • Expression “as CaCO3” — A standard way to compare different salts on the same basis. Conversion uses equivalent weights: mg/L as CaCO3 = (mg/L of ion or salt) × (50.045 / equivalent weight of species). For Ca2+ and Mg2+, one mole of ion corresponds to one mole of CaCO3 on the “as CaCO3” basis.
  • Units — Common reporting units: mg/L as CaCO3, ppm as CaCO3 (numerically equal to mg/L for dilute aqueous solutions near 25 °C), milliequivalents per liter (meq/L). 1 meq/L as CaCO3 = 50.045 mg/L as CaCO3. Typical hardness classification (USGS): soft 0–60 mg/L, moderately hard 61–120 mg/L, hard 121–180 mg/L, very hard >180 mg/L (all as CaCO3).
  • Soap titration principle — Hardness ions form insoluble curdy precipitates with soap (sodium salts of fatty acids), preventing lather. The volume of soap solution required to form persistent lather is proportional to hardness after correcting for the lather factor.
  • Complexometric titration with EDTA — Ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA), in its disodium salt form, forms stable 1:1 complexes with Ca2+ and Mg2+: M2+ + Y4− → MY2−. At pH 10 ± 0.1 with ammonium buffer, Eriochrome Black T (EBT) acts as a metallochromic indicator: colored complex with Mg2+ (wine‑red). At the endpoint, EDTA binds the metal ions, indicator becomes free (blue).
  • Indicator chemistry (EBT) — EBT forms a weak red MIn− complex with Mg2+/Ca2+. During titration, EDTA removes M2+ from MIn−. Endpoint: wine‑red to clear blue. A trace of Mg2+ is often ensured (by buffer or by adding Mg-EDTA) so that the initial red color is definite and Ca2+ alone still gives a clear endpoint.
  • Assumptions behind EDTA titration —
    • All hardness is due to Ca2+ and Mg2+.
    • Complexation is 1:1 (metal:EDTA) and goes to completion at pH ~10.
    • No significant interfering metal ions (Fe3+, Cu2+, Al3+) or they are masked.
    • Temperature is near room temperature; ionic strength is moderate.
  • Interferences and masking — Metals like Fe3+, Al3+, Cu2+, Mn2+ can also complex with EDTA and EBT, giving high results. Masking agents (e.g., cyanide—seldom used now for safety, triethanolamine, or tartrate) or prior removal/precipitation are used if present.
  • Determining different hardness fractions by EDTA —
    1. Total hardness: Direct titration at pH 10 with EBT.
    2. Calcium hardness: Titrate at pH ~12–13 with murexide indicator; Mg2+ precipitates as Mg(OH)2, so EDTA measures only Ca2+.
    3. Magnesium hardness: TH − Ca hardness.
    4. Carbonate hardness: Equal to alkalinity (as CaCO3) if TH ≥ alkalinity; otherwise CH = TH. Non‑carbonate hardness NCH = TH − CH.
  • Boiling method (for understanding only) — Boiling converts bicarbonate hardness to precipitates; filtering and retitrating gives permanent hardness. Modern practice uses alkalinity relationships rather than actual boiling in labs.

Exact statements commonly needed in exam answers:

  • Definition: “Hardness of water is the property due to dissolved polyvalent metal ions (mainly Ca2+ and Mg2+) that prevents lathering with soap and causes scale, and is expressed as mg/L (ppm) as CaCO3.”
  • Statement of 1:1 EDTA complexation: “At pH ≈ 10, EDTA forms a 1:1 complex with Ca2+ and Mg2+: M2+ + Y4− → MY2−; hence moles of EDTA at endpoint equal moles of total hardness ions present.”
  • Color change in EBT titration: “Wine‑red (metal–indicator complex) to clear blue (free indicator) at endpoint.”

What to draw and label (diagram description):

  • Draw a standard titration setup: a burette clamped on a stand labeled “EDTA solution (M mol·L−1)”, zero mark at top; below, a 250 mL conical flask labeled “Water sample (V mL) + NH4Cl/NH4OH buffer (pH 10) + 2–3 drops EBT indicator”. Show swirling motion arrows. Add a side note: “Initial color: wine‑red; Endpoint: blue”. Optionally show a separate 100 mL volumetric flask labeled “Standard CaCO3 solution for EDTA standardization”.

Derivations often asked:

  1. Derivation of hardness (as CaCO3) from EDTA titration volumes
  • Let C_EDTA = molarity of EDTA (mol·L−1), V_EDTA = volume of EDTA used (mL), V_sample = volume of water sample (mL). Moles EDTA = (C_EDTA × V_EDTA/1000). By 1:1 stoichiometry, moles of CaCO3 equivalent in V_sample are the same. Mass of CaCO3 equivalent in the sample aliquot = moles × M(CaCO3) (100.09 g·mol−1). Concentration (mg·L−1 as CaCO3) = [mass in grams × 10^6] / [V_sample in mL × 10^3]. Simplifying, Hardness (mg·L−1 as CaCO3) = (C_EDTA × V_EDTA × 100.09 × 1000) / V_sample. If using normality/equivalent concepts: 1 meq/L as CaCO3 = 50.045 mg/L; then hardness (mg·L−1 as CaCO3) = (N_EDTA × V_EDTA × 50.045 × 1000) / V_sample.
  1. Relation between ppm, mg/L, and meq/L
  • For dilute aqueous solutions, density ≈ 1 kg·L−1, so 1 mg/L ≈ 1 ppm. Since 1 equivalent of CaCO3 = 50.045 g, 1 meq/L corresponds to 50.045 mg/L as CaCO3.
  1. Soap titration calculation idea
  • Let V_s = soap solution volume with sample to get lather; V_d = soap volume with distilled water (lather factor). Effective soap volume for hardness = V_s − V_d. Calibration with standard hard water (SHW) of known hardness H_SHW (mg/L as CaCO3) and volume V_SHW gives “soap solution factor” K (mg as CaCO3 per mL of soap) = (H_SHW × V_SHW/1000) / (V_s,SHW − V_d). Then, sample hardness H_sample = K × (V_s − V_d) × (1000/V_sample).

Safety and good practice:

  • Wear goggles and gloves; EDTA and ammonia buffer are irritants. Verify pH = 10.0 ± 0.1 for EBT. Rinse burette with EDTA before filling. Avoid air bubbles in burette tip.

Formulas

Hardness (mg·L−1 as CaCO3) = (C_EDTA × V_EDTA × 100.09 × 1000) / V_sample where C_EDTA is EDTA molarity (mol·L−1), V_EDTA is EDTA volume used (mL), V_sample is sample aliquot (mL). Applies to EDTA titration at pH ~10 with 1:1 stoichiometry. 100.09 g·mol−1 is molar mass of CaCO3.

  • Hardness (mg·L−1 as CaCO3) = (N_EDTA × V_EDTA × 50.045 × 1000) / V_sample N_EDTA is EDTA normality (eq·L−1), 50.045 g·eq−1 is equivalent weight of CaCO3. Use when treating EDTA in equivalents.

  • Total hardness (TH) = Calcium hardness + Magnesium hardness All as mg·L−1 as CaCO3. Calcium hardness from Ca‑EDTA titration at pH ~12–13; magnesium hardness = TH − calcium hardness.

  • Carbonate hardness (CH) = min(TH, Alkalinity as CaCO3) CH equals alkalinity if TH ≥ alkalinity; otherwise CH = TH. Units: mg·L−1 as CaCO3. Applies when alkalinity is determined independently (by acid titration).

  • Non‑carbonate hardness (NCH) = TH − CH Units: mg·L−1 as CaCO3. Assumes TH and CH are on same CaCO3 basis.

  • 1 meq·L−1 as CaCO3 = 50.045 mg·L−1 as CaCO3 Conversion factor linking equivalents and CaCO3 scale.

  • ppm (as CaCO3) ≈ mg·L−1 (as CaCO3) For dilute aqueous solutions at ~25 °C where density ≈ 1 kg·L−1.

  • Soap factor K = (H_SHW × V_SHW / 1000) / (V_s,SHW − V_d) K in mg as CaCO3 per mL soap; H_SHW mg·L−1 as CaCO3; V_SHW, V_s,SHW, V_d in mL. Applies to soap titration method.

Worked examples

  1. Total hardness by EDTA titration Given: 50.00 mL water sample; EDTA ≈ 0.01000 mol·L−1; burette reading at endpoint V_EDTA = 12.40 mL; pH 10 buffer; EBT indicator. Steps:
  1. Write formula: Hardness (mg·L−1 as CaCO3) = (C_EDTA × V_EDTA × 100.09 × 1000) / V_sample.
  2. Substitute: = (0.01000 mol·L−1 × 12.40 mL × 100.09 g·mol−1 × 1000) / 50.00 mL.
  3. Compute moles EDTA in aliquot: 0.01000 × 12.40/1000 = 1.240×10−4 mol.
  4. Mass as CaCO3 in aliquot: 1.240×10−4 × 100.09 g = 0.01241 g = 12.41 mg.
  5. Scale to per liter: (12.41 mg / 50.00 mL) × 1000 mL = 248.2 mg·L−1. Answer: Total hardness = 248.2 mg·L−1 as CaCO3.
  1. Calcium and magnesium hardness separately by EDTA Given: Same sample as Example 1. Total hardness: V_EDTA(TH) = 12.40 mL with EBT at pH 10. Calcium hardness: V_EDTA(Ca) = 8.60 mL with murexide at pH ~12. EDTA molarity 0.01000 mol·L−1, sample volume 50.00 mL. Steps:
  1. TH (as CaCO3) from Example 1 = 248.2 mg·L−1.
  2. Calculate Ca hardness: use same formula with V_EDTA = 8.60 mL. Moles EDTA = 0.01000 × 8.60/1000 = 8.60×10−5 mol. Mass as CaCO3 in aliquot = 8.60×10−5 × 100.09 g = 0.008608 g = 8.608 mg. Concentration = (8.608 mg / 50.00 mL) × 1000 = 172.2 mg·L−1.
  3. Mg hardness = TH − Ca hardness = 248.2 − 172.2 = 76.0 mg·L−1 as CaCO3. Answer: Calcium hardness = 172.2 mg·L−1 as CaCO3; Magnesium hardness = 76.0 mg·L−1 as CaCO3.
  1. Carbonate and non‑carbonate hardness using alkalinity Given: From Example 1, TH = 248.2 mg·L−1 as CaCO3. Separately measured alkalinity (as CaCO3) = 180.0 mg·L−1. Compute CH and NCH. Steps:
  1. CH = min(TH, Alkalinity) = min(248.2, 180.0) = 180.0 mg·L−1 as CaCO3.
  2. NCH = TH − CH = 248.2 − 180.0 = 68.2 mg·L−1 as CaCO3. Answer: Carbonate hardness = 180.0 mg·L−1 as CaCO3; Non‑carbonate hardness = 68.2 mg·L−1 as CaCO3.
  1. Soap titration (conceptual numerical) Given: Standard hard water (SHW) of 500.0 mg·L−1 as CaCO3; 50.0 mL of SHW requires 12.0 mL of soap solution to reach persistent lather; 50.0 mL distilled water requires 0.8 mL (lather factor). Unknown sample, 50.0 mL, requires 10.4 mL soap. Find hardness of sample. Steps:
  1. Compute effective soap volume for SHW: 12.0 − 0.8 = 11.2 mL.
  2. Soap factor K = (H_SHW × V_SHW / 1000) / (V_s,SHW − V_d) = (500.0 × 50.0 / 1000) / 11.2 = (25.0) / 11.2 = 2.232 mg as CaCO3 per mL soap.
  3. Effective soap volume for sample: 10.4 − 0.8 = 9.6 mL.
  4. Hardness in 50.0 mL aliquot = K × 9.6 = 2.232 × 9.6 = 21.43 mg as CaCO3.
  5. Convert to mg·L−1: (21.43 mg / 50.0 mL) × 1000 = 428.6 mg·L−1 as CaCO3. Answer: Hardness of sample = 428.6 mg·L−1 as CaCO3.

Common mistakes

  • Ignoring the lather factor in soap titration, giving systematically high hardness.
  • Not standardizing EDTA solution; assuming label molarity can cause 2–5% error.
  • Parallax error in burette readings; not removing the air bubble at the burette tip.
  • Misinterpreting the EBT color: endpoint is clear blue; stop at the first permanent blue that persists for ~30 seconds.
  • Using tap water for dilutions or glassware rinses; residual hardness alters results. Use distilled or deionized water.
  • Calculating carbonate hardness without measuring alkalinity or without ensuring both values are on the CaCO3 basis.

For your exam

  • Derivations: formula to compute hardness (as CaCO3) from EDTA titration volumes; relations between TH, CH, NCH; ppm–mg/L–meq/L conversions.
  • Diagrams: labeled titration setup; sample and reagent preparations.
  • Numericals: compute hardness from given titration data; calculate CH and NCH from TH and alkalinity; split Ca and Mg hardness from two titrations; soap titration with lather factor and standardization.
  • A full‑marks answer includes: clear definitions with units, balanced or net ionic equations, indicator and pH conditions, calculations with formula first then numbers with units, and final result in bold with “as CaCO3.” If relevant, state assumptions (1:1 EDTA complexation, no interferences).

Note: Water softening (zeolite, ion exchange), desalination (reverse osmosis, electrodialysis), boiler troubles, and instrumental methods (pH‑metry, conductometry) are covered in other topics; here we focus on measuring hardness before and after such treatments.

Quick check

  1. Why is hardness expressed “as CaCO3” and what is the unit used in practice?
  2. What is the color change and pH condition for EBT in EDTA titration of total hardness?
  3. A 25.00 mL sample requires 6.50 mL of 0.01000 mol·L−1 EDTA for total hardness. What is the hardness as CaCO3?

Answers: (1) To compare different hardness‑causing ions on a common equivalent basis; unit is mg·L−1 (ppm) as CaCO3. (2) Wine‑red to blue at pH ≈ 10 with NH4Cl/NH4OH buffer. (3) Hardness = (0.01000 × 6.50 × 100.09 × 1000)/25.00 = 260.2 mg·L−1 as CaCO3.

Finished this topic? Mark it so your progress, study plan and readiness keep up.

Stuck on something here?