Thin cylinders
Membrane stresses, strains and volume change in thin-walled cylindrical pressure vessels; hoop vs longitudinal stress, deformations, volumetric strain, and typical exam combinations with fluid compressibility.
Drafted with Aria, reviewed by the AiCanCode.org team · Updated . How we write and check our notes. Spotted an error? Use Give Feedback at the bottom of the page.
Why it matters
Thin cylindrical shells (pressure vessels) appear in boilers, compressed air receivers, LPG cylinders, hydraulic accumulators and pipelines. Understanding their membrane stresses and deformations lets you size thickness, check safety, estimate leakage/expansion, and link fluid compressibility with pressure rise — all common in design checks and interviews.
Key ideas
- Thin cylinder (thin-walled pressure vessel): a long, closed cylindrical shell of radius r and wall thickness t, under internal pressure p, where the wall is “thin” so stresses are nearly uniform through thickness. Thin-wall criterion used in exams: D/t ≥ 20 (equivalently r/t ≥ 10). If not satisfied, use Thick Cylinders (Lame’s theory).
- Stress state and sign convention: Take tensile stress/strain as positive. Internal pressure p is positive (gauge). The three principal (membrane) stresses at the wall are:
- Hoop (circumferential) stress, σ_H — acts around the circumference.
- Longitudinal stress, σ_L — acts along the axis.
- Radial stress, σ_r — acts through the thickness; varies from ≈ p at the inner surface to ≈ 0 at the outer. For thin walls, |σ_r| ≪ |σ_H|, |σ_L|, so we neglect σ_r in stress–strain relations (plane stress assumption).
- Assumptions (thin-cylinder model):
- t ≪ r (D/t ≥ 20), so membrane theory applies; 2) material is homogeneous, isotropic, linearly elastic with modulus E and Poisson’s ratio ν; 3) pressure is uniform over the internal surface; 4) no significant bending near supports/openings (consider a long cylinder, far from end effects); 5) negligible weight effects and temperature effects (see Thermal Stresses topic if needed); 6) small strains.
- Derivation of hoop stress (outline): Cut the pressurised cylinder by a diametral longitudinal plane and balance forces on one half. Pressure resultant on the projected rectangle (2r × L) is p·(2rL). The resisting tensile force is 2(σ_H·t·L). Equilibrium: p·2rL = 2σ_H tL ⇒ σ_H = p r / t = p D / (2 t).
- Derivation of longitudinal stress (outline): Cut by a plane normal to the axis (through a closed end). Pressure resultant on the circular area is p·(πr²). Resisting tensile force in the wall (around circumference) is σ_L·(2π r t). Equilibrium: pπr² = σ_L·2π r t ⇒ σ_L = p r / (2 t) = p D / (4 t). Hence σ_H = 2 σ_L.
- Strain relations (plane stress): Using generalized Hooke’s law (σ_r ≈ 0):
- Circumferential strain ε_θ = (σ_H/E) − ν(σ_L/E).
- Longitudinal strain ε_L = (σ_L/E) − ν(σ_H/E).
- Small-strain kinematics: change in diameter ΔD = D·ε_θ, change in length ΔL = L·ε_L, and change in radius Δr = r·ε_θ.
- Volumetric strain of the vessel’s internal volume: For V ≈ π r² L, the fractional change is ΔV/V = 2(Δr/r) + (ΔL/L) = 2ε_θ + ε_L. Substituting ε_θ, ε_L gives ΔV/V = (1/E)[σ_H(2 − ν) + σ_L(1 − 2ν)]. With σ_H = pr/t and σ_L = pr/(2t): ΔV/V = (pr/(tE))·(5 − 4ν)/2.
- Principal stresses and maximum shear: At a wall point, principal stresses are approximately σ1 = σ_H, σ2 = σ_L, σ3 ≈ 0. In-plane maximum shear = (σ_H − σ_L)/2. Absolute maximum shear (considering σ3 ≈ 0) is (σ1 − σ3)/2 ≈ σ_H/2.
- Comparison note (thin spherical shell): A thin spherical shell under internal pressure has a single uniform membrane stress σ = p r / (2 t) = p D / (4 t) (same magnitude as the longitudinal stress in a cylinder). This is for context; focus here remains on cylinders.
- Where ideal differs from real:
- Near nozzles, supports, and ends, bending and shear occur (membrane theory underestimates local stresses; see Stress Concentration, and advanced pressure vessel design).
- Radial stress is not strictly zero; for thicker walls it matters (use Thick Cylinders).
- Fabrication details (welds, rivets, joint efficiency) and inspection standards control allowable stress; these belong to design codes, not the basic SoM model here.
- External pressure can cause buckling, not covered by thin-cylinder membrane stress formulas.
Formulas
Thin-wall applicability: D/t ≥ 20 (≈ r/t ≥ 10) — D: diameter (m), r: radius (m), t: wall thickness (m). Use thin-cylinder formulas when satisfied.
σ_H = p D / (2 t) — σ_H: hoop stress (Pa), p: internal pressure (Pa), D: internal diameter (m), t: thickness (m). Applies to thin cylinders under uniform internal pressure (membrane theory).
σ_L = p D / (4 t) — σ_L: longitudinal stress (Pa), variables as above. Same applicability.
ε_θ = (σ_H / E) − ν (σ_L / E) — ε_θ: circumferential strain (dimensionless), E: Young’s modulus (Pa), ν: Poisson’s ratio (–). Plane stress assumption, thin cylinder.
ε_L = (σ_L / E) − ν (σ_H / E) — ε_L: longitudinal strain (dimensionless). Same applicability.
ΔD = D · ε_θ = (p D² / (4 t E)) · (2 − ν) — ΔD: increase in diameter (m). Derived from ε_θ with σ_H, σ_L substituted. Thin cylinder, small strain.
ΔL = L · ε_L = (p D L / (4 t E)) · (1 − 2 ν) — ΔL: increase (or decrease if 1 − 2ν < 0) in length (m). Thin cylinder, small strain (note sign; for common metals ν ≈ 0.3, so 1 − 2ν > 0, ΔL > 0).
ΔV / V = 2 ε_θ + ε_L = (1 / E)[σ_H (2 − ν) + σ_L (1 − 2ν)] — ΔV/V: vessel volumetric strain (dimensionless). Thin cylinder, small strain.
ΔV / V = (p r / (t E)) · ((5 − 4 ν) / 2) = (p D / (4 t E)) · (5 − 4 ν) — Equivalent forms using r or D. Thin cylinder, small strain.
τ_max,in-plane = (σ_H − σ_L) / 2 — maximum in-plane shear stress at the wall (Pa). Thin cylinder, plane stress.
τ_max,absolute ≈ σ_H / 2 — absolute maximum shear considering σ3 ≈ 0 (Pa). Thin cylinder, neglecting radial stress.
Water (fluid) compressibility: ΔV_f / V ≈ p / K — K: bulk modulus of the fluid (Pa). Small pressure rise, approximately uniform pressure, low Mach number (static loading).
Worked examples
Example 1 — Direct application (stresses and deformations) Given: A thin cylindrical vessel has internal diameter D = 1.0 m, length L = 3.0 m, thickness t = 10 mm, internal pressure p = 2.0 MPa. Material: E = 200 GPa, ν = 0.30. Find σ_H, σ_L, ΔD, ΔL, and ΔV.
- Hoop and longitudinal stresses Formulae: σ_H = p D / (2 t); σ_L = p D / (4 t). Numbers: p = 2.0×10^6 Pa, D = 1.0 m, t = 0.010 m.
- σ_H = (2.0×10^6 × 1.0) / (2 × 0.010) = 100×10^6 Pa = 100 MPa.
- σ_L = (2.0×10^6 × 1.0) / (4 × 0.010) = 50×10^6 Pa = 50 MPa.
- Strains and changes in dimensions Formulas: ε_θ = (σ_H/E) − ν(σ_L/E); ε_L = (σ_L/E) − ν(σ_H/E); ΔD = D ε_θ; ΔL = L ε_L. Numbers: E = 200×10^9 Pa, ν = 0.30.
- ε_θ = (100×10^6 / 200×10^9) − 0.30 (50×10^6 / 200×10^9) = 0.0005 − 0.000075 = 0.000425.
- ΔD = 1.0 × 0.000425 = 0.000425 m = 0.425 mm.
- ε_L = (50×10^6 / 200×10^9) − 0.30 (100×10^6 / 200×10^9) = 0.00025 − 0.00015 = 0.00010.
- ΔL = 3.0 × 0.00010 = 0.00030 m = 0.30 mm.
- Change in internal volume Formula: ΔV/V = 2 ε_θ + ε_L.
- ΔV/V = 2(0.000425) + 0.00010 = 0.00095. Initial volume V = π r² L = π (0.5)² × 3.0 = 0.75π = 2.3562 m³.
- ΔV = 2.3562 × 0.00095 = 0.002238 m³ ≈ 2.24×10^−3 m³.
Answer: σ_H = 100 MPa; σ_L = 50 MPa; ΔD = 0.425 mm; ΔL = 0.30 mm; ΔV ≈ 2.24×10^−3 m³ (≈ 2.24 L).
Example 2 — GATE-style combination (vessel expansion + water compressibility) A closed thin cylindrical steel tank of internal diameter D = 1.2 m, length L = 2.0 m, thickness t = 8 mm is completely filled with water at negligible initial gauge pressure. An additional ΔV_in = 3.0 L of water is pumped in. Take E = 200 GPa, ν = 0.30, and water bulk modulus K = 2.2 GPa. Estimate the final gauge pressure p and the resulting hoop stress σ_H.
Assumptions: thin-wall (D/t = 150 ≫ 20), small strains; use initial volume V in the compressibility term ΔV_f ≈ (p/K) V.
- Geometry and initial volume
- r = D/2 = 0.6 m; t = 0.008 m.
- V = π r² L = π (0.6)² × 2.0 = 0.72π = 2.262 m³.
- ΔV_in = 3.0 L = 0.0030 m³.
- Relation between added volume and pressure rise Compatibility: added volume equals vessel expansion plus compression of water: ΔV_in = ΔV_vessel + ΔV_fluid.
Formulas:
- ΔV_vessel = V (ΔV/V) with ΔV/V = (p r / (t E)) · ((5 − 4ν)/2).
- ΔV_fluid ≈ V (p/K). Thus ΔV_in = V p [ (r/(tE))·((5 − 4ν)/2) + (1/K) ].
- Compute the compliance terms
- (5 − 4ν)/2 = (5 − 1.2)/2 = 1.9.
- r/(tE) = 0.6 / (0.008 × 200×10^9) = 0.6 / 1.6×10^9 = 3.75×10^−10 Pa^−1.
- Vessel term = 1.9 × 3.75×10^−10 = 7.125×10^−10 Pa^−1.
- Fluid term = 1/K = 1 / (2.2×10^9) = 4.545×10^−10 Pa^−1.
- Sum = 7.125×10^−10 + 4.545×10^−10 = 1.167×10^−9 Pa^−1 (rounded to 1.166–1.167×10^−9).
Solve for pressure p = ΔV_in / [ V × (sum) ] = 0.0030 / [ 2.262 × 1.167×10^−9 ] = 0.0030 / 2.64×10^−9 ≈ 1.14×10^6 Pa. So p ≈ 1.14 MPa.
Hoop stress σ_H = p D / (2 t) = (1.14×10^6 × 1.2) / (2 × 0.008) = 1.368×10^6 / 0.016 = 85.5×10^6 Pa ≈ 85.5 MPa.
Answers: Final gauge pressure p ≈ 1.14 MPa; hoop stress σ_H ≈ 85.5 MPa.
Note: Using more significant digits for intermediate steps changes the last 1–2% only.
Common mistakes
- Using D where r is needed (or vice versa); remember σ_H = p r/t = p D/(2t), σ_L = p r/(2t) = p D/(4t).
- Forgetting unit conversion (mm to m), causing stresses 1000× too high/low.
- Applying thin-wall formulas when D/t is too small (thick-wall needed); always check D/t first.
- Neglecting longitudinal stress in design checks (end closures do induce σ_L = σ_H/2).
- Mixing plane stress and plane strain formulas; for thin shells use plane stress (σ_r ≈ 0).
- Getting signs wrong in strain due to Poisson’s ratio; use ε_θ = (σ_H/E) − ν(σ_L/E) and ε_L = (σ_L/E) − ν(σ_H/E).
- For volume change problems with fluids, forgetting fluid compressibility, or using ΔV_f/V = p/E instead of p/K (bulk modulus, not Young’s modulus, governs volumetric compression of a fluid).
- Using spherical-shell stress formula σ = pD/(4t) for a cylinder by mistake; that matches σ_L, not σ_H.
For GATE ME
- Quick numericals: compute σ_H, σ_L for given p, D, t; compare magnitudes (σ_H = 2σ_L).
- Deformation: find ΔD, ΔL, ΔV using E and ν; be ready to compute strains first, then dimensions.
- Combined problems: extra fluid volume pumped into a closed tank; set ΔV_in = ΔV_vessel + ΔV_fluid with K given.
- Conceptual: identify when thin-wall theory is valid; principal stresses at a wall point; maximum shear at the wall and its location.
- Comparison: recognize that thin spherical shell stress equals pD/(4t) and is uniform (context check).
- Practise dimensional consistency and clean algebra to avoid D↔r and mm↔m errors; carry SI units through each step.
Quick check
- A thin cylinder under internal pressure has which stress larger: hoop or longitudinal, and by what ratio?
- Write the expression for change in length ΔL of a thin cylinder in terms of p, D, L, t, E, ν.
- A cylindrical vessel has D/t = 12. Should thin-wall formulas be used?
Answers: 1) Hoop stress is twice the longitudinal stress (σ_H = 2 σ_L). 2) ΔL = (p D L / (4 t E)) · (1 − 2 ν). 3) No; D/t is too small — use thick-cylinder (Lame’s) equations.
Finished this topic? Mark it so your progress, study plan and readiness keep up.
Stuck on something here?