Wave–particle duality and de Broglie waves
Wave–particle duality and de Broglie waves: definitions, de Broglie hypothesis, matter-wave kinematics (E=ħω, p=ħk), phase/group velocity, Davisson–Germer electron diffraction, Bragg condition, and standard formulas with worked numericals.
Drafted with Aria, reviewed by the AiCanCode.org team · Updated . How we write and check our notes. Spotted an error? Use Give Feedback at the bottom of the page.
Why it matters
- Modern devices (scanning tunnelling microscope, quantum wells/boxes, nanomaterials) rely on wave behaviour of electrons; designing or interpreting them requires comfort with wave–particle duality.
Key ideas
Planck–Einstein relations: For a quantum of electromagnetic radiation (photon), energy E and frequency f satisfy E = h·f, where h is Planck’s constant. Angular frequency ω = 2πf gives E = ħ·ω, where ħ = h/2π.
Photon momentum: From relativity, a photon with wavelength λ carries momentum p = E/c = h/λ. This particle-like momentum explains radiation pressure and the Compton effect (treated in other topics as needed).
de Broglie hypothesis (postulate): Any particle with linear momentum p has an associated matter wave of wavelength λ given by the exact relation: λ = h/p. For a free particle, the associated sinusoidal wave can be written ψ(x,t) = A·e^{i(kx − ωt)} with p = ħk and E = ħω. Here k is the wave number (2π/λ) and ω is the angular frequency.
Exact statement (exam style): “Every material particle of momentum p is associated with a wave of wavelength λ given by λ = h/p.” Assumptions: free particle; single-valued plane wave; uses Planck–Einstein (E = ħω) and relativistic momentum–energy relations (or Bohr’s quantization for the hydrogen atom) to motivate the result.
Derivation 1 (from photon analogy): For light quanta, E = h·f = ħ·ω and p = h/λ = ħ·k. de Broglie generalized to matter: impose the same proportionalities E = ħ·ω and p = ħ·k for any particle. Then λ = 2π/k = h/p follows immediately.
Derivation 2 (from Bohr quantization; common university derivation): For an electron in a circular Bohr orbit, the angular momentum condition is mvr = nħ. If an integer number of de Broglie wavelengths fits along the circumference, 2πr = nλ. Substituting λ = h/p = h/(mv) into 2πr = nλ gives mvr = nħ, recovering Bohr’s postulate. Thus de Broglie waves are consistent with quantized orbits.
Phase velocity and group velocity of matter waves:
- Define the plane wave ψ ∝ e^{i(kx − ωt)}. The phase velocity is v_p = ω/k. For matter waves, using E = ħω and p = ħk, v_p = E/p.
- For a non-relativistic free particle, E = p²/(2m) ⇒ v_p = E/p = p/(2m) = v/2, where v is the particle speed. So phase velocity is half the particle speed (and subluminal).
- A physical particle is a wave packet: superposition of waves with nearby k. The envelope moves with group velocity v_g = dω/dk. Using E(p) and ω = E/ħ, k = p/ħ ⇒ v_g = dE/dp.
- Non-relativistic: E = p²/(2m) ⇒ v_g = dE/dp = p/m = v, i.e., the packet (and thus the particle) propagates with the particle’s speed.
- Relativistic free particle: E² = p²c² + m²c⁴ ⇒ v_g = dE/dp = pc²/E = v; and v_p = E/p = c²/v. Hence v_p·v_g = c², with v_p > c permitted because phase velocity does not carry information or energy.
Dispersion of matter waves: Because E ∝ p² for non-relativistic motion, ω ∝ k², so d²ω/dk² ≠ 0. A free-particle matter-wave packet spreads over time (dispersion). In contrast, light in vacuum is non-dispersive (ω = ck; no spreading).
Davisson–Germer electron diffraction (experimental verification):
- Setup: Electrons emitted from a heated filament are accelerated through potential V, collimated, and directed at a crystalline nickel target. A movable detector (or Faraday cup) measures current as a function of scattering angle.
- Observation: Intensity shows strong angular maxima, consistent with Bragg diffraction from crystal planes, proving electrons behave as waves with wavelength matching λ = h/p.
- Bragg condition (for constructive interference from planes with spacing d): nλ = 2d·sinθ, where θ is the glancing angle (angle between incident beam and crystal plane) or half the scattering angle in some geometries. Care must be taken to use the θ defined by the apparatus.
- Comparison: Compute λ from accelerating voltage via λ = h/√(2 m_e e V) (non-relativistic) and match with λ from the Bragg peak via λ = 2d·sinθ/n.
Electrons accelerated through a potential V:
- Non-relativistic kinetic energy: K = eV = p²/(2m) ⇒ p = √(2meV) ⇒ λ = h/√(2meV). Valid when eV ≪ mc² (for electrons, eV ≲ 10–20 keV typically keeps errors small).
- Relativistic correction (from rest): E_total = mc² + eV; p = √[(E_total/c)² − (mc)²]; then λ = h/p. This is needed for high accelerating voltages (e.g., TEMs at 100–300 kV). Equivalently, for electrons this can be written in closed form as λ = h/√[2 m_e e V (1 + eV/(2 m_e c²))], and a useful relativistic shortcut is λ(Å) ≈ 12.27 / √[V (1 + 0.978×10⁻6 V)], with V in volts.
Complementarity and measurement: Detecting which path a particle takes destroys interference (wave nature); allowing indistinguishability permits interference to appear. This conceptual link is formalized by Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle (covered as a separate topic): Δx·Δp ≥ ħ/2.
What to draw (exam diagrams):
- Electron plane wave and wave packet: draw sinusoidal wave labelled λ and a Gaussian envelope for packet; annotate v_p and v_g arrows with v_p = ω/k, v_g = dω/dk.
- Davisson–Germer setup: filament (source), accelerating anode at potential V, collimator, Ni crystal at fixed orientation, rotatable detector; show incident beam, specular direction, and diffracted direction. Label scattering angle and the glancing angle used in Bragg’s law.
- Bragg planes: parallel lattice planes separated by d, incident electron beam making angle θ with the plane, show path difference 2d·sinθ for rays reflecting from adjacent planes.
Formulas
E = h·f = ħ·ω
- E: energy (joule, J); f: frequency (hertz, Hz); ω: angular frequency (rad/s); h: Planck constant (J·s); ħ = h/2π. Applies to photons and (by postulate) to matter waves.
p = h/λ = ħ·k
- p: momentum (kg·m/s); λ: wavelength (m); k: wave number (rad/m). Photon or matter wave; exact within quantum theory.
λ = h/p
- de Broglie wavelength for any particle with momentum p (SI units as above). Exact.
K = p²/(2m)
- K: non-relativistic kinetic energy (J); m: mass (kg); valid when v ≪ c.
λ = h/√(2 m K) = h/√(2 m e V)
- Wavelength of a particle of mass m with kinetic energy K; for electrons accelerated through potential V (volt, V), with e = 1.602 176 634×10⁻¹⁹ C, use the rightmost form. Non-relativistic regime.
E_total² = (pc)² + (mc²)²
- Relativistic energy–momentum relation for any particle. E_total (J), p (kg·m/s), m (kg), c (m/s). Exact.
p = √[(E_total/c)² − (mc)²], with E_total = mc² + eV (electron from rest)
- Momentum after acceleration through V from rest (relativistic). Then
λ = h/p.
v_p = ω/k = E/p
- Phase velocity of a matter wave (m/s). For non-relativistic free particle, v_p = v/2. For relativistic, v_p = c²/v.
v_g = dω/dk = dE/dp
- Group velocity (m/s). For free particle, v_g = v (the particle speed).
nλ = 2d·sinθ
- Bragg condition for constructive interference. n: order (integer); d: interplanar spacing (m); θ: glancing angle between beam and planes (radian or degree). Geometry-dependent: ensure θ matches the plane angle definition.
Constants (SI):
h = 6.626 070 15×10⁻³⁴ J·s(exact by definition).ħ = 1.054 571 817×10⁻³⁴ J·s(CODATA 2018; check latest if needed).m_e = 9.109 383 7015×10⁻³¹ kg(electron mass; approximate to needed precision).e = 1.602 176 634×10⁻¹⁹ C(exact by definition).c = 2.997 924 58×10⁸ m/s(exact by definition).
Useful shortcut (non-relativistic electrons):
λ(Å) ≈ 12.27 / √V, with V in volts
- λ in ångström (1 Å = 0.1 nm). Accurate up to ~10–20 kV; above this include the relativistic correction. Derivation comes from λ = h/√(2 m_e e V).
Worked examples
Example 1: de Broglie wavelength of an electron accelerated through 150 V (non-relativistic) Given: V = 150 V; m_e = 9.109×10⁻³¹ kg; e = 1.602×10⁻¹⁹ C; h = 6.626×10⁻³⁴ J·s
- Formula: λ = h/√(2m_e eV)
- Numbers: 2m_e eV = 2 × (9.109×10⁻³¹ kg) × (1.602×10⁻¹⁹ C) × (150 V)
- Note: 1 C·V = 1 J, so eV here is energy in joule.
- Compute: eV = 1.602×10⁻¹⁹ × 150 = 2.403×10⁻¹⁷ J
- 2m_e eV = 2 × 9.109×10⁻³¹ × 2.403×10⁻¹⁷ = 4.381×10⁻⁴⁷ kg·J
- √(2m_e eV) = √(4.381×10⁻⁴⁷) = 6.619×10⁻²⁴ (kg·m/s)
- Unit check: √(kg·J) = √(kg·kg·m²/s²) = kg·m/s
- λ = (6.626×10⁻³⁴ J·s) / (6.619×10⁻²⁴ kg·m/s) = 1.001×10⁻¹⁰ m Final: λ ≈ 1.00×10⁻¹⁰ m = 0.100 nm = 1.00 Å (non-relativistic). This matches the shortcut: λ(Å) ≈ 12.27/√150 ≈ 12.27/12.247 ≈ 1.00 Å.
Example 2: Bragg angle for electron diffraction from crystal planes Given: Interplanar spacing d = 0.203 nm; accelerating voltage V = 150 V (from Example 1); first-order (n = 1)
- Find electron wavelength from V: λ ≈ 0.100 nm (from Example 1)
- Bragg condition: nλ = 2d·sinθ ⇒ sinθ = nλ/(2d) = 0.100/(2×0.203) = 0.100/0.406 = 0.246
- θ = arcsin(0.246) = 14.2° Interpretation: A strong diffracted intensity maximum is expected at glancing angle θ ≈ 14.2° for these planes. In an experiment, ensure θ corresponds to the angle defined with respect to the crystal planes (apparatus often reports a related scattering angle).
Example 3: Phase and group velocities for a 10 keV electron (use non-relativistic estimates; check validity) Given: K = eV = 10 keV = 10,000 eV; m_e = 9.109×10⁻³¹ kg; e = 1.602×10⁻¹⁹ C
- Convert energy: K = 10,000 × 1.602×10⁻¹⁹ J = 1.602×10⁻¹⁵ J
- Particle speed (non-relativistic): v = √(2K/m_e) = √(2 × 1.602×10⁻¹⁵ / 9.109×10⁻³¹) m/s
- Numerator: 3.204×10⁻¹5; divide by 9.109×10⁻³¹ ⇒ 3.517×10¹5
- v = √(3.517×10¹5) = 5.93×10⁷ m/s ≈ 0.198 c (non-relativistic is fair but nearing limit; relativistic correction would slightly reduce v)
- Group velocity: v_g = v = 5.93×10⁷ m/s
- Phase velocity (non-relativistic): v_p = v/2 = 2.97×10⁷ m/s
- Relativistic check (optional): Electron rest energy m_ec² ≈ 511 keV. Here K/E_rest ≈ 10/511 ≈ 0.0196 (≈2%). Non-relativistic formulas are acceptable to within a few percent. Final: v_g ≈ 5.93×10⁷ m/s, v_p ≈ 2.97×10⁷ m/s (non-relativistic estimates).
Common mistakes
- Using λ = h/√(2meV) for very high voltages (≫20 kV) without relativistic correction; this underestimates momentum and overestimates λ.
- Forgetting SI units and constants (e.g., using eV directly in λ = h/√(2mK) without converting to joule), leading to wrong magnitudes.
- Confusing phase and group velocity. The physically meaningful propagation of a particle (and information) is with v_g, not v_p. Phase velocity can exceed c in the relativistic expression and that is not a violation because it carries no information.
- Treating a single plane wave as a localized particle. A real particle is a packet (superposition); plane waves are delocalized and non-normalizable in the strict sense.
- Misapplying the shortcut λ(Å) = 12.27/√V to ions or neutrons. That numerical constant is specific to electrons of charge magnitude e and rest mass m_e.
For your exam
- Short notes: Davisson–Germer experiment (apparatus, observation, inference); explain dispersion of matter waves and relation v_g = dE/dp; complementarity and role of which-path info; limitations of non-relativistic approximation.
- Derivations: (i) λ = h/p from Planck–Einstein and plane wave; (ii) de Broglie + standing-wave condition 2πr = nλ ⇒ Bohr’s mvr = nħ; (iii) v_p and v_g for free particle (non-relativistic and relativistic cases), including v_p·v_g = c² for the relativistic free particle.
- Numericals: Compute λ for electrons or neutrons given V or K; use Bragg law to find θ or d; include unit conversions and a diagram to show the geometry.
- Diagrams: Clean sketches of Davisson–Germer setup and Bragg planes with all distances/angles labelled; a wave packet sketch with v_p and v_g arrows.
- Full-marks answers include: clear statement of laws with assumptions, neat algebra with steps, correct units/constants, a labelled diagram when geometry is involved, and a brief concluding sentence interpreting the numerical result.
Quick check
- Write the de Broglie wavelength of a particle of momentum p and state the meaning and SI unit of each symbol.
- For a free non-relativistic particle, what are the phase and group velocities in terms of the particle speed v?
- An electron (from rest) is accelerated through 100 V. Estimate its de Broglie wavelength using the shortcut.
Answers: (1) λ = h/p; λ (m), h (J·s), p (kg·m/s). (2) v_p = v/2 and v_g = v. (3) λ(Å) ≈ 12.27/√100 = 1.227 Å = 0.123 nm.
Finished this topic? Mark it so your progress, study plan and readiness keep up.
Stuck on something here?