Macroscopic momentum balance and forces on bends

The steady-flow control-volume momentum balance and how to use it for jet impact, nozzles, reducers, pipe bends and the sudden-expansion loss.

Drafted with Aria, reviewed by the AiCanCode.org team. Spotted an error? Use Give Feedback at the bottom of the page.

Why it matters

Fluid changing speed or direction pushes on whatever turns it. Pipe bends, reducers, tees, nozzles and spray jets all carry reaction forces that must be resisted by anchors, thrust blocks and pipe supports; under-designed supports at a bend are a classic cause of leaks and failures in high-pressure lines. The macroscopic (control-volume) momentum balance is the tool that gives these forces without knowing the detailed flow inside.

Key ideas

Control-volume form of Newton's second law. For a fixed control volume (CV): Sum of external forces on the fluid in the CV = rate of accumulation of momentum inside the CV + net rate of momentum outflow through the control surface. For steady flow the accumulation term is zero, so ΣF = Σ(ṁV)_out − Σ(ṁV)_in. This is a vector equation: write it separately for x, y and z.

Forces that act on the fluid in the CV.

  • Pressure forces at the inlet and outlet sections, p·A, always acting into the CV, normal to each section.
  • The force exerted by the pipe wall (bend, nozzle, vane) on the fluid, R — the unknown usually sought. The force of the fluid on the bend is −R (Newton's third law).
  • Body force (weight of fluid in the CV) — include for vertical bends; negligible in horizontal ones.
  • Use gauge pressures. The atmosphere acts on the outside of the pipe too, so its contribution cancels.

Momentum flux and correction factor. The momentum flow through a section is β·ṁ·V, where V is the average velocity and β the momentum correction factor: β = 4/3 for laminar flow in a pipe, about 1.02 for turbulent flow (usually taken as 1).

Typical cases.

  • Jet striking a fixed flat plate normally: the jet leaves sideways, so F = ρQV = ρAV².
  • Jet on a moving plate (speed u away from the jet): relative velocity V − u; F = ρA(V − u)².
  • Jet deflected by a fixed curved vane through angle θ: force along the jet = ρQV(1 − cosθ); maximum, 2ρQV, for θ = 180°.
  • Pipe bend or reducer: momentum change plus pressure forces at both ends; pressures linked by Bernoulli (or with a head loss).
  • Nozzle at the end of a hose: the fluid accelerates, the nozzle is pulled forward (downstream) by the fluid — the force the coupling bolts must carry.
  • Sudden expansion: the momentum balance, with the eddy pressure on the annular face equal to upstream pressure, gives the Borda–Carnot loss h_L = (V₁ − V₂)²/2g.

Angular momentum. Applying the same balance to moment of momentum gives torque on lawn sprinklers and on pump and turbine impellers (Euler's turbomachine equation).

Formulas

  • ΣF = Σ(β·ṁ·V)_out − Σ(β·ṁ·V)_in — steady-flow momentum balance (vector, N); ṁ = ρQ (kg/s), V (m/s).
  • p₁·A₁ − p₂·A₂ + R_x = ṁ·(V₂ − V₁) — straight horizontal reducer or nozzle along x; R_x is the force of the wall on the fluid (N), p gauge pressures (Pa), A areas (m²). For a bend, write one such equation per axis using the velocity and pressure-force components.
  • F = ρ·A·V² — jet on a fixed plate normal to it (N); A jet area (m²).
  • F = ρ·A·(V − u)² — jet on a single plate moving away at u (m/s).
  • F = ρ·Q·V·(1 − cosθ) — jet deflected through θ by a fixed vane, force along the jet axis.
  • h_L = (V₁ − V₂)²/(2g) — loss at a sudden expansion (m).

Worked examples

Example 1 (standard). A water jet of 50 mm diameter and velocity 20 m/s strikes a fixed flat plate held normal to it. Find the force on the plate, and the force if the plate moves away from the jet at 5 m/s.

  1. A = (π/4)(0.05)² = 1.963 × 10⁻³ m².
  2. Fixed plate: F = ρ·A·V² = 1000 × 1.963 × 10⁻³ × 20² = 785.4 N.
  3. Moving plate: F = ρ·A·(V − u)² = 1000 × 1.963 × 10⁻³ × 15² = 441.8 N. Fixed: ≈ 785 N; moving: ≈ 442 N.

Example 2 (GATE level). A horizontal 90° reducing bend carries 0.15 m³/s of water. The inlet (diameter 0.30 m) flows in the +x direction at a gauge pressure of 200 kPa; the outlet (diameter 0.20 m) discharges in the +y direction. Neglect losses. Find the force of the water on the bend.

  1. Velocities: V₁ = Q/A₁ = 0.15/0.07069 = 2.122 m/s; V₂ = 0.15/0.03142 = 4.775 m/s.
  2. Outlet pressure by Bernoulli: p₂ = p₁ + ½ρ(V₁² − V₂²) = 200 000 + 500 × (4.503 − 22.797) = 190 853 Pa.
  3. ṁ = ρQ = 150 kg/s.
  4. x-balance on the fluid: p₁A₁ + R_x = ṁ(0 − V₁), so R_x = −p₁A₁ − ṁV₁ = −(14 137 + 318) = −14 455 N.
  5. y-balance on the fluid: R_y − p₂A₂ = ṁ(V₂ − 0), so R_y = p₂A₂ + ṁV₂ = 5996 + 716 = 6712 N.
  6. Force of water on the bend = −R: F_x = +14 455 N (along the inlet flow), F_y = −6712 N (opposite to the outlet flow).
  7. Resultant = √(14 455² + 6712²) = 15 938 N, at tan⁻¹(6712/14 455) = 24.9° below the +x axis. F ≈ 15.9 kN, directed 24.9° from the inlet direction, away from the outlet side. Note that pressure contributes about 95 % of the force; the momentum terms are small at these velocities.

Common mistakes

  • Treating velocity as a scalar: on a 90° bend with equal speeds the momentum change is ṁV√2, not zero.
  • Forgetting the pressure terms, which usually dominate in pressurised pipes.
  • Using absolute instead of gauge pressure.
  • Confusing the force on the fluid with the force on the bend (opposite signs).
  • Using ρAV² for a moving plate without switching to the relative velocity.
  • Omitting the fluid weight for a bend in a vertical plane.

For GATE CH

Expect jet-impact numericals (fixed and moving plates, curved vanes), force on a reducer, nozzle or bend with pressure terms, and the sudden-expansion loss derived from the momentum balance. Practise setting up the control volume, choosing axes, and writing one component equation at a time with correct signs.

Quick check

  1. A jet of 0.002 m² area at 15 m/s hits a fixed normal plate. Find the force.
  2. Through what angle should a fixed vane deflect a jet to receive the maximum force?
  3. Should gauge or absolute pressure be used in the bend force balance?
  4. What is β for fully developed laminar pipe flow?

Answers: 1. 1000 × 0.002 × 15² = 450 N. 2. 180°. 3. Gauge. 4. 4/3.

Interview questions

All Fluid Mechanics interview questions

Try answering each one aloud before you open it.

  1. 1.What is the macroscopic momentum balance in fluid mechanics?Concept

    The macroscopic momentum balance is a principle used to analyze the momentum of a fluid system. It involves applying Newton's second law to a control volume, considering the rate of change of momentum within the volume and the net force acting on it. This balance helps in understanding how forces and momentum are distributed in fluid systems, especially in complex geometries like bends and junctions.

  2. 2.Explain how forces act on bends in a piping system.Concept

    Forces on bends in a piping system arise due to the change in momentum as the fluid changes direction. The fluid exerts a force on the bend, and according to Newton's third law, the bend exerts an equal and opposite force on the fluid. These forces can be calculated using the momentum balance equation, considering the mass flow rate, velocity change, and pressure difference across the bend.

  3. 3.Why is it important to consider the forces on bends in fluid systems?Application

    Considering the forces on bends is crucial for the structural integrity and safety of piping systems. Unaccounted forces can lead to mechanical failure, leaks, or even catastrophic events. Proper design ensures that the piping system can withstand these forces, preventing damage and ensuring efficient operation.

  4. 4.What happens if the forces on a bend are not properly accounted for in a piping system?Application

    If the forces on a bend are not properly accounted for, it can lead to excessive stress on the piping material, resulting in deformation, fatigue, or failure. This can cause leaks, disrupt fluid flow, and potentially lead to safety hazards or environmental damage.

  5. 5.How does the angle of a bend affect the forces acting on it?Application

    For a constant-area bend turning the flow through angle θ, the change in momentum flux has magnitude 2ṁV·sin(θ/2), and the pressure forces at the two ends combine in the same way, 2pA·sin(θ/2). So the resultant force grows with turning angle: zero for a straight pipe, √2 times the single-leg value for a 90° bend, and a maximum of twice the single-leg value for a 180° return bend. The resultant acts along the bisector of the bend, pointing outward, which is where thrust blocks or anchors are placed.

  6. 6.Explain the role of pressure in the momentum balance for a bend.Concept

    Pressure plays a significant role in the momentum balance for a bend as it contributes to the net force acting on the control volume. The pressure difference across the bend, combined with the change in momentum due to velocity change, determines the total force exerted by the fluid on the bend. This pressure force must be considered alongside the momentum change to accurately assess the forces involved.

  7. 7.Why do pipelines need anchors or thrust blocks at bends, especially when bellows expansion joints are used?Application

    At a bend the internal pressure and momentum change produce an unbalanced resultant force, mostly from the pA terms in a pressurised line. In a continuous welded line the pipe wall carries this as tension, but a bellows expansion joint cannot carry axial load, so the pressure thrust (pressure times the bellows effective area) must be taken by anchors on either side. Buried water mains and large lines therefore have concrete thrust blocks at bends, tees and dead ends.

  8. 8.Water flows at 2 m/s with a mass flow rate of 5 kg/s through a horizontal 90° bend of constant diameter. Neglecting pressure forces, what is the momentum force on the bend?Numerical

    Momentum is a vector, so take components. With inlet along +x and outlet along +y, the fluid loses ṁV = 10 N of x-momentum flux and gains 10 N of y-momentum flux. The bend therefore receives 10 N in +x and 10 N in −y, a resultant of 10√2 ≈ 14.1 N at 45° to both legs. In a real pressurised line the pA terms at each end usually add far more than this.

  9. 9.In a straight horizontal diffuser the fluid slows from 3 m/s to 1 m/s at a mass flow rate of 4 kg/s. What net force acts on the fluid in the flow direction?Numerical

    The steady momentum balance gives ΣF = ṁ(V₂ − V₁) = 4 × (1 − 3) = −8 N. So the net of the pressure forces at the two ends and the wall force must be 8 N directed against the flow. This net force on the fluid is not the same as the force on the diffuser; to get that you must add the p·A terms at both sections.

  10. 10.How does the diameter of a pipe affect the forces on a bend?Application

    The diameter of a pipe affects the velocity of the fluid and the cross-sectional area, both of which influence the momentum change and pressure forces on a bend. A larger diameter typically results in lower velocity for the same flow rate, reducing the momentum change and thus the forces on the bend. However, the increased area can lead to higher pressure forces, which must also be considered.

Finished this topic? Mark it so your progress, study plan and readiness keep up.

Stuck on something here?

PreviousEuler and Bernoulli equations with applicationsNext Dimensional analysis, Buckingham pi theorem and similitude